Being part of a business model such as a franchise provides different advantages, as you can enter an established market with a settled system and a recognized brand. However, as we mentioned in previous posts, franchise agreements can raise questions about intellectual property and the respective patent rights when third parties are involved.
One of the most common questions is, what happens when a franchisee develops an innovation while operating under a franchise? Can a franchisor own your ideas and rights? To clarify this, in today’s article, we will explain the intricacies of IP in franchising, how to protect your innovations and provide insights into franchisors’ and franchisees’ perspectives.
If you are interested in this topic, we recommend you to keep reading the content we created especially for you, this way you will have more information to know how to protect your IP rights in these situations.
What types of intellectual property are protected in franchise agreements?
Firstly, it is important to know the different types of intellectual property protected in a franchise agreement to understand the ownership’s areas of opportunity.
These agreements may include the protection of the following IPs to have a formal foundation of the business operation and avoid possible disputes:
1.- Patent protection
Patent protection provides the opportunity to safeguard inventions and innovations and grants the holder exclusive rights to use, sell, or license the creation. In a franchise agreement, patents cover proprietary processes, equipment, or technology used for the franchise system, such as organization software or unique cooking devices.
While specifying the rights that each party has of these patents, it is also essential to clarify whether new patents developed by franchisees become the property of the franchisor or not. This step is crucial to avoid any potential disagreements and the loss of your intellectual property, whether it involves your ideas or your brand.
2.- Copyright protection
In a franchise, copyright is fundamental, as it protects the company’s original works, such as training manuals or marketing materials. These are the foundation of a franchise system, which is why their unauthorized use could undermine the brand’s consistency or jeopardize its success if they fall into the hands of competitors.
Therefore, franchise agreements grant franchisees the right to use copyrighted materials but must legally prohibit their reproduction or distribution outside the franchise’s scope.
3.- Trade secret protection
Formulas, recipes, business strategies, and customer databases are confidential information that must be protected to safeguard a franchise. These elements are part of trade secret protection, which needs to be included in franchise agreements to manage the business adequately.
Generally, franchisees must sign a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) to keep trade secrets confidential.
4.- Trademark protection
Trademark protection must also be included in franchise agreements, as it safeguards brand elements like product names, logos, slogans, and more, ensuring the franchise’s identity. These marks are usually licensed to franchisees to allow them to legally exploit the IP within strict guidelines to maintain brand integrity. If any misuse or unauthorized alteration of these elements is detected, it can result in legal consequences.
Who owns the rights to a franchise innovation?
As you may have noticed, a franchise agreement involves disclosing the owner’s terms and conditions. In the case of developing a franchise innovation, the ownership will depend on the terms outlined in the franchise agreement and the circumstances under which the innovation was created.
In this sense, there can be two possibilities where the ownership may vary on the agreements between the parties:
Franchise related innovation
The franchisor may claim ownership if the creation of the franchisee is a tool, technology or part of the processes of the franchise to improve the system, especially if the agreement includes clauses requiring franchisees to assign the rights of franchise-related innovation to the franchisor.
Unrelated franchise innovation
If the innovation, on the other hand, is a new product developed independently of the franchise process or system, the rights are often assigned to the franchisee. However, there may be disputes if the franchisor believes the innovation was developed from franchise resources or knowledge.
This may also vary depending on the signed terms of the franchise agreement. Therefore, it is important to maintain a clear understanding of the established disclosures, as well as keep direct communication with all parties involved.
How to protect your ideas as a franchisee?
Now that you are familiar with these possibilities, it is essential to understand another way to protect your original ideas; this way, you can stay as a proactive franchisee while safeguarding your intellectual property.
1.- Review the franchise agreement
As we mentioned before, the franchise agreement is the foundation of your relationship with the franchisor and its business. Consequently, you must carefully review the clauses related to IP ownership to understand your rights and obligations within patents, copyrights, and trade secrets and their possible improvements in the future. Knowing this, you will better understand the legal impact of your future innovations.
2.- Find legal advice from a franchise attorney
Regarding Intellectual Property Law, it is fundamental to consult a professional to avoid any legal issues in the future.
Seek the help of a franchise lawyer Miami to navigate complex agreements and clarify any doubts about the ownership of your innovations. They will offer assistance in identifying your legal limitations and opportunities.
3.- Maintain records of your innovations
Keeping documentation of the development of your ideas will help you if any dispute for ownership arises. Maintain the record of timelines, resources, and any evidence that proves the development is yours.
4.- File patents independently
Lastly, if your innovation is unrelated to the franchise system, consider applying to register your patent independently. This step can prevent any misunderstandings and strengthen your legal position as the owner of your intellectual property.
Franchisor’s perspective: How to correctly handle patent rights?
We understand that from a franchisor’s perspective, the protection of the franchise identity and ownership is one of the main considerations. That is why effectively managing patent rights is crucial to fostering innovation while protecting their brand and operations.
Hereunder, we explain some recommendations for handling the patent rights in a franchise agreement correctly:
Define IP ownership
Be explicit about the state of ownership for any innovation developed within the franchise. Establishing the terms from the beginning reduces ambiguity and prevents disputes.
Encourage innovation through incentives
Consider offering royalty-sharing agreements or incentives to franchisees who develop valuable innovation. This strategy will encourage an environment for creativity and improvement.
Protect trade secrets and IP of your business
Implement security measures such as non-disclosure agreements to safeguard confidential information that could be compromised through innovation disputes.
These practices will offer a balanced approach to strengthen your franchise business and the relationship with your collaborators.
As you noticed from the previous information, intellectual property plays a central role in franchising, hence the importance of understanding the rights and obligations you may have, both as franchisee and franchisor, to maintain the success of your business and protect your innovations.
If you liked our content, remember to share it on social media and stay tuned to our blog updates. At Sanchelima, we always offer you the latest news about franchise and patent law.
